The Philadelphia
Story
review by Patti
Naretta
I was skeptical about watching this movie at first because
I have this common misconception that anything filmed in black
and white is boring (even though a few of my favorite movies
are in black and whiteI dont know why I still hold to this
myth, but I guess old habits die hard). I am also not too thrilled
about Katherine Hepburn. It mostly has to do with her distinctive
voice, which I dont vehemently dislike; its more like casual
annoyance. But I had just recently seen and enjoyed Cary Grant
in North By Northwest and I have always been a fan of James
Stewart since growing up with Its a Wonderful Life as obligatory
Christmas-season viewing. And not only are both actors featured
in the movie, but Stewart also won the Academy Award for Best
Actor in his role; so I decided to give it a whirl.
You are invited to the wedding of Tracy Lord (Hepburn) and
George Kittridge. Tracys ex, C.K. Dexter Haven (played by Grant,
spiteful but still in love with his former spouse), arrives
at her familys mansion the day before the wedding, with a writer
and a photographer from Spy magazine. Writer, Mike Conner (Stewart)
and photographer, Liz Imbrie, are instructed by Haven to pretend
to be cousins of the Lord family so that they may stay as guests
in the mansion and report on the famous heiress wedding. Tracy
guesses Conner and Imbries intentions and plays as though she
thinks they are her cousins, when she knows that they are actually
tabloid journalists.
Circumstances escalate when after a party the night before
the wedding, Mike Conner and Tracy Lord end up making drunken
overtures of love to one another in the mansions garden. Imagine
how both George and Dexter feel when they see Mike carrying
Tracy, both in bath robes, with Mike loudly slurring Somewhere
Over the Rainbow. As a natural reaction, one of them punches
Mike in the face. And youll never guess who it was. By this
point in the movie, Tracy has been alternately in love with
each of the three male leads, and additionally they are all
in love with her simultaneously! And just how is a girl to
choose from three dashing men? Two of which are Cary Grant
and James Stewart???
Ah, where to begin in the review. Well start with the fact
that I enjoyed it thoroughly. The story was compelling, the
characters were charming, and the movie was cut in such a way
that I never felt as though my time was being wasted on insignificant
side-plots. I was also impressed at the intricacy of the plotthe
twists, the turns, and the way things worked out in the end.
Another of my faults, in addition to assuming that all black
and white movies are boring, is that I also used to believe
that all of their plots were simple and juvenile. I like when
I am proven wrong in this regard.
Knowing some of the history behind the film also made me appreciate
it more. Trivia such as there was only time for one take for
each scene. Everything was done in one. Hepburn executed a
swan dive into a pool without a stunt double (AND in one take!).
I was especially enthralled with a scene where Stewart starts
to ad-lib some of his drunken lines to Grants character by
adding hiccups in between pauses. Seeing Jimmy Stewart hiccupping
and slurring while Cary Grant sat by, obviously trying hard
to deliver his lines, a smile cracking at the sides of his
lips and avoiding eye-contact with Stewart so he didnt totally
lose it, was probably the most entertaining thing Id seen in
a long time. I think the knowledge enhanced my experience,
made me feel a greater connection to the movie, knowing the
story behind the hilarious scene. It was like having an inside
joke with two of the greatest actors of all time. My only tiny
qualm is that the movie seemed to end too soon.
Bottom Line: Would watch the movie again. Would quote the
movie. Would consider adding it to my DVD collection.
Four and a Half out of Five Stars. (half star deducted for
the itty-bitty slight bias I have against Hepburn)
respond to Patti
Here
|